Portrayed by Chris Owen Appeared in: At the prom, everything seems hopeless for the four boys until Vicky asks the girl that Chuck Sherman claimed to have bedded about her "first time". She proclaims to everyone at the prom that she and Sherman did not have sex at Stifler's party, leaving Sherman embarrassed and making him wet himself. He reappears in the second film where he goes to the party hosted by Jim and his friends.
Later he mulls around at the party in a depressed mood, having abandoned his "Sherminator" mantra from the first film due to his abject failure with girls. By chance, he begins talking to the rejected Nadia, who is also depressed, and the two hit it off almost instantly. He reappears in American Pie Presents: Band Camp when Matt Stifler plays a prank on the school band.
Sherman, who is now the school's guidance counselor, decides that a worthwhile punishment would be for Stifler to attend band camp. He told Stifler he got married, had a son named Furlong and later divorced. He moved on quickly and when he sees the most popular girl in high school everyone had a crush on. He is the younger brother of Steve Stifler and second son of Janine Stifler.
His first name was not revealed until his appearance in the first spin-off Band Camp. He was featured in the first two installments in the theatrical series and then given his own straight-to-DVD spin-off, American Pie Presents: Matt was first introduced to the series alongside his elder brother watching Nadia, the foreign exchange student, strip-tease in Jim Levenstein's bed room. His next appearance was in American Pie 2, where he requested to stay along with his brother in their summer beach house.
In this film, set a year after the first, Matt begun to show his interest in girls and even at his young age showed signs of the infamous Stifler Sex Drive.
Although Steve teaches him several lessons on how to get girls, when it comes to the night of the party he simply puts Matt on watch-dog duty. Angered, Matt waits outside and begins to aimlessly work his walkie-talkie. Much to his surprise and pleasure, however, he accidentally comes across the signal of the girls across the street.
After being asked who's speaking, an eager-to-impress Matt states they are in fact talking to "the Stiffmeister". He manages to impress the girls enough to meet up with him but his prize is cut short when his brother intervenes successfully wooing the girls into bed with him. Matt leaves the next day, his hands full of porn videos, bidding goodbye to Steve and his friends.
Matt's next appearance was as a starring role in Band Camp, which sees him eager to join the family business of making amateur porn films. On the day of the seniors graduation, he and his friends spray the bands instruments with pepper spray. The prank, however, is cut short after Matt accidentally left the pepper spray open and leaking in his pocket evidently burning his penis.
The band, unable to see due to the spray, accidentally destroy the set inadvertently revealing Matt as the culprit. As punishment, he must endure his summer at Band Camp. Now classed by his old friends as a bandee, Matt tries to prove himself by filming his fellow band members sexual activities throughout the summer. However, as the summer progresses, Matt suddenly develops a friendship with his fellow campers and romantic feelings for the drum major Elyse, whom he had recently had an off screen relationship with prior.
With the help of Mr Levenstein, Matt realizes that living in his brother's shadow and following in his footsteps isn't what he should be doing. By the end of the film, Matt reforms himself much like his older brother did in American Wedding.
However, he is still content on insulting his peers and still has an active sex drive but appears far less selfish, nasty and bullying. Matt's next appearance is a simple cameo in the second spin-off Naked Mile , where he is introduced as a picture on his younger cousin, Erik's, wall as a "legendary Stifler Boy", implying that whilst he learnt his lesson in Band Camp, he still acts with Stifler traits.
He is mentioned again later by Mr. Levenstein after Erik asks if he could ask for some advice. He has another cameo in Book of Love as a name written on the rent card of "The Bible" The School's Sex Manual , implying that he must have rented it out at some point during his school years.
Evidently, Matt looks up to his older brother as a role model, and initially hopes to be just like him. However, after the events of Band Camp, he realizes that this future isn't as good as it previously seemed. Matt is notable to be possibly the only member of the Stifler family, aside from his older brother in American Wedding, to realize that the "Stifler Legacy" isn't necessarily a good one.
He is also different from other Stiflers as Mr. Levenstein notes that people actually want to like him but they find it difficult due to the way he acts. The two first appear in American Pie , where they are seen at Stifler's Party. John also is a choir member. Though their role was brief and minor, their appearance in the film has been significant as the term "MILF" has since become popular due to the usage in the film by John and Justin.
They are also friends with the core four Kevin, Jim, Oz and Finch. Their next appearance is in American Pie 2 in a slightly larger role.
They are first seen at Stifler's party, once again. They are waiting to get into the bathroom, when they come across Paul Finch, who slept with Stifler's Mom in the first film. John and Justin admire Finch and ask him how he did it. They are next seen when John, in a memorable scene, urinates off of a balcony and onto Stifler's head, unintentionally. Justin covers his back as he does so. The two walk off and are not seen again until the climatic party scene at the beach house.
They are seen getting drunk and partying with various women. The last we see of them is the two of them walking off on the beach, with John saying "Am I gonna have a hangover? The two serve as two ushers at Jim and Michelle's wedding. They are tasked with looking after Jim's grandma, but end up putting her inside a broom closet instead.
John and Justin are last scene outside of Stifler's Mom's room window, peering in to see her taking a bath, where they see Paul Finch emerge from the water, performing cunnilingus on her. They once again chant "MILF", before the window steams up and obscures their view as Finch goes back under the water.
Their last appearance is in American Reunion. John has a much bigger role in this, and his character is expanded upon, while Justin only makes a brief cameo. John is first seen pulling up alongside Jim's car, as he has just crashed. He is panicking and asking if he is okay, until he realizes it is Jim. The two become reacquainted and talk to each other. John reveals he is organizing the reunion. He also mentions that he and his "MILF" buddy Justin are not on good terms right now, and would rather not speak of him.
He sees Kara get out from Jim's lap, and, thinking it's Michelle, assumes she is performing fellatio on him. John laughs and gives a thumbs up to Jim before driving off. He is again seen at Stifler's party, where he almost blows Jim's cover by saying he saw Jim and Michelle last night, but then walks off before he can elaborate on it.
He later watches Oz compete on the Celebrity Dance-Off video. He helps in the fight by throwing a weapon to Finch. When the cops arrive, John runs out of the house. At the reunion, John hands out name tags to all the class of ' He is last seen in the bleachers, watching Stifler and Finch's Mom having sexual intercourse.
He is drinking heavily and is depressed, due to Justin's absence. Despite his effeminate behavior, according to the directors' commentary on American Reunion, John is a heterosexual.
Portrayed by Jennifer Coolidge Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion Although the role of Jeanine is very limited, the character becomes important mostly at the end of the movies. Jeanine Stifler is the divorced mother of Steve and Matt Stifler.
When Jim and his friends are at Stifler's house they see a picture of her. They are impressed and all want to have sex with her. Jeanine turns up at the end of the movie. She meets Paul Finch while he is exploring the house and enters the billiard room where she is sitting.
Jeanine tries to seduce Paul although the opposite is also true and they have sex on the billiard table. They are caught by Steven. In American Pie 2 there are many references to this incident. Jeanine is expected to be at the beach house where Jim, Paul, Steven and the others stay during their vacation. Paul, still in love with Jeanine, learned to control his sexual drifts via meditation and hopes to have sex with her once again.
Stifler is certain this will not happen again. Just before the boys head home, a car turns up driven by Jeanine. She asks Paul if she can drive him home, to which he agrees. Stifler, who is still in the house, is told a lost tourist was asking the way and Paul decided to travel home on his own. However, Stifler is suspicious about the guys claims, demanding them to tell him who is that tourist in the car. In the next scene, Jeanine and Paul have sex in the car.
Once again, Jeanine turns up at the end of the movie. She tells Paul not to be interested in her anymore, to which he agrees. However, it is now revealed they had sex more than twice.
They get excited and leave. In next scene, they have sex while taking a bath.